Was Odysseus a Good Leader? Free Essay Sample for Students

Douglas MacArthur once wisely noted that only a true leader has the confidence to stand alone, the courage to make tough decisions, and the compassion to listen to the needs of others. This quote perfectly captures the essence of Odysseus, the central character in The Odyssey by Homer. This mythical Greek hero embodies many of the qualities required of a leader. But how good was he truly, and can he be considered someone willing to go to any lengths for others? Let’s examine the key traits of this character to provide a definitive answer.

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

Order now

Leadership in crisis: Odysseus’ commitment to returning home

After the long and grueling Trojan War, Odysseus did everything he could to ensure that he and his crew returned home to Ithaca. Fate dealt him numerous challenges, but he brought his men back. Jon Gordon once said that the difference between good and great leaders lies in their ability to inspire people to believe in themselves. This idea finds real confirmation in the story of Odysseus. His ability to maintain morale, unity, and the determination to return home at any cost commands respect. Despite the deaths of many crew members at the hands of Cyclopes, giants, and a six-headed monster, the remaining crew stayed disciplined and loyal to their leader until the end. This ultimately allowed the ancient Greek heroes to return home.

The encounter with Scylla and Charybdis is a strong testament to Odysseus’s leadership qualities. When six crew members fell overboard and were devoured by the terrifying monster, the rest froze in fear, unsure of what to do. This is a typical shock situation where the team becomes paralyzed because the mission isn’t going as planned. In response, Odysseus managed to pull his men out of their stunned state and motivated them to keep rowing. At this moment, he acted as both a leader and a crisis manager, preventing the mission from falling apart and effectively saving the remaining crew from certain death.

Inspiring and decision-making

A good leader understands how crucial team spirit is for achieving success. This is why Odysseus’s conversation with Telemachus in Eumaeus’s hut is a prime example of leadership. When Telemachus doubts the success of their mission to overthrow all of the suitors and questions whether the gods are truly on their side, Odysseus motivates him with the right words. His plan, confidence in his own speech, and enthusiasm convince Telemachus that everything will go as planned. This is the essence of leadership: igniting the spark of hope and pushing the team forward, even when there are no visible signs of positivity.

Strong decision-making sets Odysseus apart as a true leader, as he doesn’t get caught in a cycle of doubts, past failures, or overanalyzing the odds of failure. He can assess the situation and make the best decision, even when the chances of success are slim. For example, when stranded on the island of the Cyclopes, Odysseus’s crew is trapped in the giant Polyphemus’s hut. The Cyclops plans to eat all the travelers and manages to devour two right in front of the horrified crew. This is where Odysseus’s lightning-fast decision-making shines through.

He quickly devises a plan, wounds the Cyclops in the eye, and blinds him. Additionally, he convinces the pain-stricken giant that his name is “Nohbdy,” which roughly translates to nothing is wrong in the Cyclops' language. As a result, the other giants do not rush to help their comrade, assuming he’s simply out of his mind. Furthermore, Odysseus’s crew clings to the bellies of the Cyclops’ large sheep to sneak out of the hut unnoticed. If this isn’t an example of quick and effective decision-making, what is? For the crew, their leader’s resourcefulness becomes their only salvation.

Reclaiming his home and commitment as a core leadership quality

A true leader knows when to act, how to utilize available resources, and how to implement a plan by delegating the right roles to each team member. Yes, Odysseus must overthrow 108 suitors to reclaim his home. For many, such a situation would seem like a stalemate. But Odysseus devised a bold plan that worked like clockwork. He instructed Telemachus to return home and keep his leader’s return a secret.

Sometime later, disguised as a beggar, Odysseus managed to infiltrate his own home. The weapons of all 108 suitors had already been hidden, leveling the playing field and allowing Odysseus and his team to eliminate the threat. The suddenness and swiftness of his actions caught the numerically superior opponents completely off guard. This case perfectly demonstrates that dedication to a cause and the ability to plan complex operations make Odysseus an effective leader.

People tend to follow decisive leaders who are ready to take action. Their ability to make important and timely decisions showcases their leadership qualities in the best possible way. For an essential conversation with the blind prophet Tiresias, Odysseus dares to descend into the underworld of Hades. Understanding the complexity and danger of the mission, he leads his crew forward. Odysseus knows that only his example can inspire the team to embark on such a daring venture. Fortunately, Odysseus's bold action proves successful and delivers the desired results.

Personal sacrifice for leadership

A good example of leadership is the strategy Odysseus’s crew used to sail past the Sirens. He knew the crew would be curious and tempted to hear the secrets whispered by these mythical creatures. He ordered them to plug their ears with wax and tie him to the mast. This way, he could hear everything the Sirens said but could not succumb to the temptation to steer toward them. Meanwhile, the crew carried out their roles on the ship effectively and managed to sail past the Sirens without any losses.

This example demonstrates that Odysseus is a capable leader. He is willing to make sacrifices, find compromises, and take actions that help his team succeed. Another example of his personal sacrifice for the greater good is his behavior upon returning to Ithaca. He is consumed by longing for his wife and the desire for a quick reunion. At the same time, he recognizes the danger he would bring to her and their son. For this reason, he devises a complex plan, patiently works toward his goal, and reveals his identity only when it is most advantageous.

This is exactly how a true leader should act. A special strategy, perfect timing, and clear role distribution are essential when the odds of success are low. Odysseus understands this and personally takes part in the ruse that allows him to regain control of Ithaca and reunite with his family. He knows when to be patient cand unning, and give precise instructions to others. This is why he is a great leader, orchestrating the process like a conductor with an orchestra. Every action he takes has a purpose and leads to success.

Conclusion

As mentioned earlier, a true leader inspires, motivates, takes initiative, and makes the right decisions. Throughout the long and arduous journey home, Odysseus demonstrates that he is worthy of this title. His crew faces unforeseen challenges but receives clear and effective commands from their leader. Odysseus does not succumb to panic, confusion, or procrastination. He understands there is only time to lead his team and achieve their goal, and he makes no effort.

The loyalty of his crew throughout the long journey home also highlights him as a true leader. Weary from war, endless wandering, and unexpected losses, the men would not follow just anyone. Only Odysseus gives them faith that tomorrow will come and that Ithaca awaits them with open arms. In this sense, Odysseus’s leadership qualities are undeniable and require no further proof.